Naming a baby is kind of wild, isn’t it? It’s this sweet little detail that somehow holds so much weight. You want something meaningful, something you both love (which is a feat in itself), and maybe something that doesn’t land her in a kindergarten class with four others who answer to the same name.
That’s where this list comes in.
These are the names that didn’t crack the current top 50—but honestly? They deserve a moment. They’re familiar, feminine, and full of charm. These beautiful baby girl names are not too trendy, not too rare—just that perfect in-between.
So if you’re looking for a name that feels like your own little secret (without being too “out there”), you’re in the right place.
Before we go much deeper into these beautiful baby girl names – Who is The Labor Mama and Why Am I Here?
Hey friend! I’m Lo – also known around here and social media as The Labor Mama. I’ve spent my nursing career in labor, delivery, and postpartum, have birthed 4 of my own babies, have labored thousands of mamas at the bedside, have taught thousands of students online, and have even delivered a few speedy little babies with my bare hands (oops).
Here at TLM, I offer online classes about birth, postpartum, newborn care, and breastfeeding to empower you the way everyone should be. The education + support I offer gives you experience, evidence, and empathy; you’re getting all of my years of “clinical” RN knowledge, honestly combined with my real experiences as a mama and a nurse. These are not your average hospital classes (those won’t do it, I promise), and honestly, birth, postpartum, and breastfeeding don’t follow a textbook or protocol anyway. You need to know so much more than that!
If you want to connect with me further, head to Instagram. There are hundreds of thousands of us over there learning together daily.
A note: This post may include affiliate links. This means if you make a purchase after clicking a link, I will earn a small commission (thank you)! Rest assured, this comes at no additional cost to you. You can read TLM’s full disclosure here.
Why Choose a Name Outside the Top 50?
It’s not just about being different—it’s about finding a name that fits your story. These names:
- Feel stylish, but not overdone
- Are often timeless, classic, or rising quietly in popularity
- Pair well with trendy or vintage middle names
- Let your little one stand out in a crowd just enough
The Name List: Beautiful Baby Girl Names You’ll Love (That Aren’t in the Top 50)
(Organized by vibe, because let’s be honest—we all have a different idea of a beautiful baby girl name)
Soft & Sweet Baby Girl Names
- Mira – Meaning “peace” or “wonder,” this one is gentle and strong.
- Annie – A warm, cozy classic that still feels fresh.
- Celia – Light and graceful, with vintage roots.
- Della – Understated charm and totally nickname-worthy.
- Faye – Short, dreamy, and quietly magical.
- Maisie – Playful and sweet with Scottish flair.
- Lena – Simple, pretty, and surprisingly international.
- Rosie – Floral and friendly without being too formal.
Literary + Vintage Vibes
- Mabel – “Lovable” and making a slow-but-steady comeback.
- Sylvie – French twist on Sylvia, meaning “from the forest.”
- Opal – A gemstone name with 1920s sparkle.
- Cleo – Chic and punchy with Egyptian roots.
- Ramona – Spunky and classic, thanks to Beverly Cleary.
- Greta – A little glam, a little vintage.
- Louisa – Feels literary and elegant (hello, Little Women).
- Dorothy – “Gift of God”—and you get Dot, Dottie, or Thea.
Nature-Inspired & Fresh
- Juniper – Botanical and fun, with the adorable nickname June.
- Laurel – Sleek and nature-rooted, like a sister to Olive or Hazel.
- Sage – Peaceful and wise.
- Briar – Edgy and earthy all at once.
- Flora – Delicate and floral, but surprisingly underused.
- Wrenley – Modern, but with a natural twist.
- Marin – Coastal, breezy, and beautiful.
Names With Global Flair
- Amara – Has roots in multiple languages, often meaning “grace” or “eternal.”
- Esme – French for “beloved.”
- Ines – Chic and simple, with Spanish/Portuguese roots.
- Noa – A soft, modern Israeli favorite.
- Zara – Royal and radiant.
- Nina – Simple, strong, and works around the world.
- Amina – Elegant and meaningful in Arabic-speaking communities.
Feminine but Not Overdone
- Colette – Classic French style with major cool-girl potential.
- Rhea – Mythological and modern.
- Talia – Soft, melodic, and Hebrew for “gentle dew.”
- Verity – A virtue name that feels bold and beautiful.
- Willa – Understated, warm, and full of charm.
- Elodie – Like Melody, but fresher and French.
- Carmen – Fiery, classic, and musical.
- Holland – Place-inspired and full of personality.
Tips for Choosing the Right Name (That’s Not Overused)
- Say it out loud with your last name. Over and over. Seriously.
- Think about nicknames—are you good with the natural ones?
- Say it with the middle name – and write it all down together. The number of times my husband has nixed names because of how they all go/look together – so many!
- Picture yourself saying it 100 times a day (because…you will).
- Ask yourself: Does this name feel like her?
- Don’t rule something out just because it’s a little different—it might just be the one.
P.S. If you’re in the baby-naming stage, you’re probably also thinking about all the other big decisions that come with pregnancy and birth.
If you want to feel educated, empowered, and confident heading into labor— I’m ready to help you there too! My course Your Body, Your Birth is a game-changer for you. It’s packed with real talk, evidence-based education, and tools to help you advocate for the birth experience you actually want.
Still deciding?
You might also love these name lists:
Naming your baby girl is one of those rare decisions that’s both a huge responsibility and a total honor. I hope this list gave you a few names to jot down, circle back to, or whisper to your bump just to see how it sounds.
And hey—if you’re still deciding or just LOVE name talk, come tell me what’s on your shortlist. I live for this stuff.
Happy naming, mama. You’ve got this. 💛
xx – Lo
More resources (and freebies!) for you to take a peek at:
- Comprehensive Birth Plan and Birth Priorities templates
- A complete Third Trimester Checklist
- The RN + mama of 4 Ultimate Packing List
- The Labor Mama online birth, baby and breastfeeding classes for every family
Liked this post? Don’t forget to pin it!
